Monday, March 29, 2010

Class Notes 3/29

Causes of Gulf War I / Iraq's invasion of Kuwait (1990-1991)

Political Causes:
  • Personal ambitions of Saddam Hussein - desire to be the leader of the Arab world, desire for power
  • Poor WWI settlements (specifically the mandate system) help cause a border dispute between Iraq and Kuwait (different interpretation, long term cause)
  • The United States should have warned Saddam Hussein not to invade Kuwait (another interpretation)
Economic Causes:
  • Kuwait waging economic warfare on Iraq (over-pricing oil, reducing Iraq's oil revenue)
  • The United States did not want one man/country to have control over 20% of the world's oil supply
  • If Saddam conquered Saudi Arabia, Iraq would control approximately 50% of the world's oil
USA, Saudi Arabia lead a United Nations effort to expel Hussein from Kuwait

August 3, 1990- USSR + USA agree to work together against Iraq.

Question: Is this the day the Cold War ended and the War on Terror began?

The United Nations fully supported the USA leading a military force to liberate Kuwait.

UN Security council voted unanimously to support action against Iraq.

Practices
  • Over 500,000 US soldiers assembled
  • Massive air campaign lasts from January 17 to February 23, causing Iraqis to surrender by the thousands by the time the ground war started.
  • Three phases of air war: gain air superiority, shatter Saddam's army and weapons capability, soften up Saddam's forces for a ground attack

Friday, March 26, 2010

Class Notes 3/26

Social Effects
  • 1,000,000 dead
  • 400,000 Iraqis, 500,000 - 600,000 Iranians
  • Iran and Iraq still hate each other
  • Continuing religious conflict between Shi'ite and Sunni Muslims
  • Kurds in the North hate Saddam Hussein after gas attacks in 1988
  • Hatred by Iran toward the USA ("Great Satan"), which supported Iraq in the war and shot down an Iranian passenger plane (290 dead)
Economic Effects
  • Both economies destroyed
  • Iraq $70 billion in debt
  • Iran increases trade with USSR
Political/Foreign Policy Effects
  • No major territorial changes
  • Saddam Hussein and Ayatollah Khomeini remain in power
  • Iraq invades Kuwait on August 2, 1990, hoping to regain lost wealth and control Kuwait's oil resources
  • Beginning of a strong US military presence in the Persian Gulf region (1987-2010)
  • Iran and Russia/USSR develop closer relations
  • Iran gains nuclear technology from Russia

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Class Notes 3/27

Both Iran and Iraq use religion to inspire soldiers
  • Martyrdom is promised to all soldiers
  • Iranian keys to heaven and "warriors of god" (red headbands)
  • November of 1980- Saddam Hussein declares the war a jihad
  • Kuwait loans Iraq $40 billion to prevent the spread of radical Islam
  • The US sides with Iraq for (partly) similar reasons
  • Iranians carry their own coffins to the front
  • Iranians recruit teenagers to clear minefields (compare to Hitler Youth/Kamikaze pilots)
Naval Warfare
  • The United States works indirectly with Iraq to blockade Iran and protect oil tankers in the Persian Gulf
  • American flags were put on Kuwaiti oil tankers to protect them
  • 1987- USS Stark is accidentally hit by a missile from an Iraqi aircraft
  • 1988- US accidentally shot down an Iranian passenger jet (290 died)
  • The Persian Gulf was mined
Iraqis use poison gas
  • Basra in 1986 vs. Iranian army- Iraq lures Iran into a kill zone and releases mustard gas
  • 1988 in Northern Iraq- Kurdish uprising, Hussein quells the rebellion with mustard gas, 5,000 civilians dead
Aerial Bombing
  • Both sides bombed capital cities (Iran- Tehran, Iraq- Baghdad)

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Class Notes 3/24

Causes
  • Personal ambition of Saddam Hussein
  • Saddam's desire to be the most powerful leader in the Arab world
Practices
  • Blitzkrieg- Iraq attacks across a 500 mile front. Tanks (Soviet-made) support infantry, MIG fighters (Soviet-made) hit military targets and oil facilities
  • Iraq seizes the Al-Faw Peninsula and parts of Khuzestan
  • The war turns into a stalemate + war of attrition
  • Iraq uses poison gas
  • Bombing cities
  • Both sides make the conflict a jihad (a holy war)
  • All soldiers (both sides) who die in war are promised a spot in paradise

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

HW 9

Causes of World War I
  • Imperialism: European nations (Germany, France, Britain) competed for land and colonies.
  • Miscalculation: Germany believed that with the Schlieffen Plan they would be able to quickly win the war.
  • Revolution: Serbia/Austria-Hungary, assassination of the archduke
  • Alliances: European countries allied with each other
Causes of the Iran-Iraq War
  • Imperialism: Saddam Hussein attempted to unite the Arab world under his rule
  • Miscalculation: Hussein believed that attacking Iran during the chaos that followed Iran's revolution in 1979 would give him an easy victory (expected a two-week war)
  • Revolution: Iranians overthrow the Shah two different times (once in 1953 and again in 1979)
  • Religion: Shi'ite Muslims in Iran, Sunni Muslims in Iraq
  • Cold War: USA and USSR both had large parts in arming Iran and Iraq in the years leading up to the Iran-Iraq War.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Class Notes 3/22

1979- Saddam Hussein becomes dictator of Iraq until 2003
  • Baath Party
1953- Iranians overthrow the Shah, set up a democracy
  • US restores the Shah back to power. The Shah rules until 1979.
1979- Shah of Iran is overthrown a second time
  • Set up Islamic Republic
  • Iran is a theocracy (religious government)
  • Took 33 Americans hostage
  • Ayatollah Khomeini becomes leader of Iran
1980- Saddam Hussein invades Iran
  • Believes Iraq will have an easy victory due to the chaos following Iran's revolution
  • May have been a miscalculation- the war lasted 8 years with over a million deaths (about 300,000 Iraqis and 500,000+ Iranians) and no territory gained
  • Desire to become dominant ruler in the Arab world
  • Unite the Arab world

Sunday, March 21, 2010

China Paper 2 (Part 2)

5. Evaluate the domestic policies of Mao.

Economic:
  • Collectivization
  • 5 Year Plan/Great Leap Forward
Social:
  • Hundred Flowers
  • Cultural Revolution

The domestic policies of China were changed dramatically under Mao Zedong after his rise to power in 1949. Some of the most notable of these changes were caused by new economic policies, such as collectivization and the use of "Five Year Plans," both of these being methods that had been used earlier in history by the leaders of Soviet Russia in order to improve their economy. Other important domestic policies included Mao's "Hundred Flowers" policy and the Cultural Revolution, methods used by Mao seemingly for the purpose of purifying China's Communist Party and keeping its leader in power.

Mao seems to have borrowed much of his economic policy from the USSR. When Mao established the People's Republic of China in 1949 after the Chinese Civil War, one of his highest domestic priorities was to collectivize the nation's agriculture. This meant that, rather than peasants owning smaller, individual farms, large groups of peasants would join together to share a much larger collectivized farm to work on. In order to carry out this type of land reform, Mao had to take the land needed for collectivized farms from wealthy landowners. This was done largely through class warfare, in which Mao used propaganda to encourage the country's less wealthy peasants to rise against landowners and take their farms, often violently. It is important for historians to note that this was very similar to Stalin's Great Terror, in which Stalin attempted to collectivize Russia's agriculture by turning the lower class against the more powerful farmers and landowners known as kulaks, so that collective farms, or kolkhozy, could be formed. The actual process of collectivization was very successful under Mao's leadership, but it is unclear how effective the policy was economically, due to the large amount of propaganda surrounding the topic. Regardless of this, collectivization was clearly unable to succeed when faced with the famines that occurred from 1958 to 1961, which are sometimes referred to as "the Bitter Years."

Another domestic policy adopted by Mao was the use of Five Year Plans, also used by Russia. The idea of this policy was to set a number of specific economic goals to be achieved within a period of five years. One of these plans, which Mao called the Great Leap Forward, began in 1958 with the ending year being 1963. In this time, Mao set goals for China's industry and agriculture that many historians today see as unrealistic. The reasoning behind Mao's apparent confidence in this plan was that China's vast population alone would be enough to turn the nation into a modern industrial state, removing the need for experts in this matter. In reality, however, this was plan was clearly flawed, and as a result it was devastating to China's economy, as well as its people. There was a particularly emphasized focus on steel production, which was set as a priority even over the production of food. Peasants, unwilling to disobey Mao for fear of being labeled "rightists" or "reactionaries," were force to work hard for long periods of time doing their best to produce steel. However, due to the lack of experts working on this, the steel was produced inefficiently. Meanwhile, the country's agricultural situation was constantly worsening. Because peasants were exhausted by their work on improving China's industry, there were very few people left able to work on the fields. For this reason, many people today cite the Great Leap Forward as the cause of the famines that occurred during the Bitter Years.

  • Hundred Flowers: Mao encouraged the people to speak their minds about China, but labeled them as reactionaries and arrested them when they spoke against him, the government, or communism.
  • Cultural Revolution: Mao encouraged certain groups, such as China's youth and students, to start a revolution against teachers and certain government leaders who he felt were turning to capitalism. It could be said that this was an attempt by Mao to maintain his own power.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

China Paper 2

2. Assess the social and economic causes of the Chinese Civil War.

While there was certainly a number of important economic causes that must be considered when studying the Chinese Civil War, the conflict seems to have been primarily caused by the social reactions of the Chinese people to the events occurring in the world around them. Economic conditions within China led to unrest among the people, while social changes throughout the entire world caused the people to reconsider their traditional values and ideals.

One long-term economic cause of the Chinese Civil War was the influence on China by foreign nations. In the beginning of the twentieth century, many Western countries, such as Britain, France, and the United States, had gained a large amount of economic control over various areas in China. These areas became known as "spheres of influence," because of the influence that these nations had over the economy in the areas they controlled. The Manchu dynasty, which ruled China at the time, allowed this to happen, accepting foreign influence on the country. This resulted in the spreading of Western culture, often in terms of business and religion. Many people, feeling a strong sense of nationalism, were unhappy with how the Manchu dynasty let this international economic situation dominate China.

Multiple movements against the government took place because of this, including the Boxer Rebellion in 1900 and the Revolution of 1911, which finally deposed the Manchus from power. The reason for this being a cause of the Chinese Civil War is the lack of unity after the downfall of the Manchus; numerous factions thought that they could do a better job of governing China than the Manchus did, but there was little agreement between these groups regarding which one should take control. The two most important groups were the Communists and the Nationalists, or Guomindang, which were the combatants during the civil war that followed.

One major social cause of the Chinese Civil War was the Russian Revolution in 1917. This conflict was very similar in many ways to the one that took place in China. The people of Russia were unhappy with their Tsarist government and the influence of capitalist values on their country, and so a large number of them adopted the new social ideology of Marxism. These people started a revolution against the government, overthrowing the Tsar and establishing a communist government under the leadership of Vladimir Lenin. The idea of Communism spread to China after the Manchu dynasty was overthrown and the country was ruled largely by warlords and by Sun Yatsen's Guomindang. In 1922, the Chinese Communist Party was founded, with the hopes of changing the social structure of China in the same way that it was changed in Russia.

Another economic cause of the war was the May 4th Movement, which occurred in 1919. During the First World War, China lost the port of Kiaochow to Germany, and then to Japan. Kiaochow was an important area to China's trade. After the war, when land was being redistributed in the Treaty of Versailles, China had expected Kiaochow to be returned by Japan. However, the port was left in Japan's ownership, causing China to protest. The protests known as the May 4th Movement included boycotts against Japan, which increased tension between the two countries leading up to World War II, in which Japan invaded China again, this time attacking Manchuria. This may seem to be a relatively indirect cause, but it served to divide China further on the issue of interacting with Japan and with other foreign nations.
  • New Tide- social movement with a focus on modern ideas such as freedom and equal rights, as well as on the elimination of old fashioned ideas.
  • Counterclaim that the May 4th Movement and the influence of foreign nations could be seen as social causes, while the Russian Revolution was an economic cause in some ways

Sorry, I wrote what I could of my first essay in about 1 hour and 10 minutes, but I ran out of time preparing for Model UN. I will finish the Paper 2 as soon as possible.

Paper 1 Practice

7. In Source A, Deng Xiaoping is discussing the state of China’s economy in 1962 and how he thought it could be improved at that time. Historians studying the Great Leap Forward might consider this to be very valuable as a primary source; there are specific numbers for the amounts of grain produced in different years, and the weather that helped cause a major food shortage and famine is mentioned. However, it is very likely that this source is twisting the truth in some ways in order to make Mao’s regime look better. The aforementioned numbers may have been exaggerated, and the changes caused by the Great Leap Forward to not seem to be considered as a factor in the decrease in food production.

Source B offers a different interpretation of the Great Leap Forward than what many historians believe. The author states that Mao’s strategy was not entirely faulty, but that it was carried out ineffectively. This is a relatively recent source, and it is evident that the author has reviewed other interpretations of this event considered them when writing his own opinion. This source may be limited by the fact that it was not written by a person who actually experienced the Great Leap Forward. It is also possible that some of the data he has relied on has been manipulated by the Chinese government.

8. Source D appears to be correct in claiming that the Great Leap Forward “proved an unmitigated disaster for the Chinese economy and people.” Whether the Great Leap Forward failed because of unrealistic ideals or because of poor implementation, it was entirely unsuccessful and it failed to maintain China during a few particularly difficult years.

Mao’s reliance on large numbers peasants and insistence on neglecting the use of experts was one important cause of this disaster, while the focus on industry, specifically steel production, was not helpful either. Because of these things, peasants were overworked and were unable to efficiently produce food, and because of their lack of industrial knowledge, they were not able to produce steel as effectively as experts might have been able to.

Mao’s plan failed to survive the unfortunate weather conditions that afflicted China. Droughts and floods destroyed what little food the peasants were able to produce, resulting in a famine that killed nearly 20 million people.

Friday, March 12, 2010

Class Notes 3/12

Cultural Revolution:
  • Mao purged enemies, similar to Stalin's Great Terror
  • Mao tried to "purify" the communist party, in order to avoid repeating Capitalism or being like the Nationalists.
  • People were arrested for criticizing Mao's wife
  • China considered both the United States and USSR to be imperialists and threats
  • Russia was seen as the bigger threat, so China tried to talk to the US (President Nixon's visit to China)

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Class Notes 3/9

Treatment of Opposition:
  • People who spoke against Mao were often called "Rightists"
  • Rightists were arrested and forced to do hard labor
  • China shelled the Nationalists on Taiwan. Kruschev was not happy about this, because it could have caused a superpower war between Russia and the United States. Russia cut off its relations with China in 1960.
  • Mao restricted Tibetans' freedom of religion, kicked out the Dalai Lama
Totalitarianism:
  • Terror: The people of China were afraid of disobeying Mao, so they agreed to follow his economic policies during the Great Leap Forward.
  • Even some of the most important Communist officials felt disconnected from Mao.
Propaganda:
  • Communes competed with each other in order produce the most grain. They often made up information to make people think that they were producing more grain than they actually were. For example, some faked pictures showed grain that was so thick that it could support the weight of children.
  • Mao did not let people know about the famine during the Bitter Years (1959-62). He did not allow peasants to go to different communes.

Monday, March 8, 2010

HW 7

  1. Mao's aims included turning China into a modern industrial state, gaining the support of the people, eliminating his opposition, and collectivizing agriculture.
  2. Mao tried to use 5-Year Plans similar to what was done in the USSR in order to industrialize his country, setting certain economic goals to reach within 5 year periods. To gain the support of China's people, Mao introduced his "100 Flowers" policy, which encouraged everyone to say what they thought of their nation. Mao also eliminated much of his opposition, labeling those who disagreed with him as "reactionaries" and punishing them. Collectivization, another major aim of Mao's regime, was achieved through land reform, which redistributed land from wealthier people and landowners to groups of peasants.
  3. Mao's 5-Year Plans were a legal method of achieving his economic aims, as were his land reform laws. However, he also used force in some cases, arresting people who spoke against his government through the 100 Flowers policy, and having many landowners killed in order to make land reform easier.
  4. The Great Leap Forward was in some ways a cause of the Three Bitter Years that China experienced. In his attempt to industrialize China as quickly as possible, Mao took too many people away from agricultural work, causing the amount of food produced to decrease. This made China less prepared to deal with the floods and droughts that occurred afterward.
  5. Mao's 100 Flowers policy seemed to be a form of propaganda, giving the people of China the illusion that their opinions were considered by the government. Mao's apology regarding the failure of the Great Leap Forward could be interpreted similarly; one could say that Mao was showing more care for his people than he actually had. A third example of propaganda is how Mao turned China's lower class peasants against the land owners during his attempts at collectivization.

Class Notes 3/8

Great Leap Forward 1958-63 (China's Second 5-Year Plan)
  • Example of a high level of totalitarianism (Mao had a lot of control)
Aims
  • Industrialize China as quickly as possible
  • Produce a food surplus
  • Create a modern industrial economy to compete with the USSR and the capitalist West
Formation of Communes
  • A method of increasing government control (Communist Party controlled decisions)
  • By 1958, 90% of the population had been placed into 26,578 communes

Friday, March 5, 2010

Paper 1 Practice 3/5

"Mao's use of terror and propaganda were his most effective methods of winning support of the peasants and common people." To what extent do you agree with this claim?

This claim is largely accurate; Mao made very effective use of propaganda and terror during his rise to power in China, with propaganda being particularly helpful toward achieving the goal of gaining the support of the common people. Source A points out that life in Communist controlled "liberation areas" was very appealing to peasants who lived in Guomindang China, because the news had spread that the Communists gave their people more freedom and abandoned certain unpleasant traditions such as forced marriages and the murder of unwanted children. This source also shows an example of Communist propaganda, portraying peasants working together to help the Red Army fight Japan. The fact the Communists seemed to support the idea of war with Japan while the Nationalists did not made many people side with the Communists.

Source B seems to argue that it was Mao's economic policy, specifically his methods of land reform, that gained the support of many peasants. A counterclaim to this might be that it was not the land reform itself, but rather Mao's promises of successful land reform in contrast with the poor economic policies of the Nationalists, that appealed to peasants, making this another example of the use of propaganda.

Source C states that "Mao's most formidable weapon was pitilessness," supporting the claim that terror had a large role in increasing Mao's support. The use of terror was very effective at decreasing opposition to the Communists, because Mao was ruthless with his enemies. However, it was not as effective as propaganda in terms of actually gaining the support of the peasants.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Causes, Practices, and Effects of the Chinese Civil War Assessment

Explain two major political causes of the Chinese Civil War.

One major political cause of the Chinese Civil War was the downfall of the Manchu dynasty, which ruled China until 1912. Many Chinese people saw the Manchus as being weak, because they had let China become heavily influenced by foreign nations and cultures. Several Western countries had established spheres on influence in China, where they had large amounts of economic control. In addition to this, Christianity was spreading very quickly in the area. The fact that the Manchus had allowed all of this to happen caused multiple revolutions, such as the Boxer Rebellion and the Revolution of 1911. Certain groups of people felt that they could do a better job ruling China than the Manchus did. The contest for power between these groups after the Manchu dynasty collapsed was an important cause of the civil war that followed.

Another political cause was the Russian Revolution, which started in 1917. This revolution occurred due to the increasing popularity of communism, with major leaders in the movement including Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin. The communist party in Russia began a violent revolution against the tsarist dictatorship that ruled over them. The events that happened in China seem to have been inspired by this revolution in some ways. The political, social, and economic ideals of the Soviet Union eventually reached China, resulting in the formation of the Chinese Communist Party in 1922. This party became one of the two major factions that would fight in the Chinese Civil War, with the other being the Nationalists led by dictator Chiang Kaishek.

Analyze three strategies or tactics that were most helpful in the Communists winning the Chinese Civil War.

The three strategies that were most helpful to the Communists were the use of guerrilla warfare, attempts to gain the support of the common people of China, and the use of assistance from Russia. Using guerrilla warfare against the Guomindang was largely Mao's idea. The communists used indirect tactics, such as leading Nationalists into their territory where they could be ambushed or isolated from help and supplies. They would also lead raids on the Nationalists at night and destroy any infrastructure that might help their enemies. This was essential to the Communist victory, because the Guomindang had a much larger and better equipped military, so the Communists likely would have been defeated if they attacked Chiang Kaishek's forces head-on.

The Communists also ensured that they received the support of China's peasants. They took advantage of the fact that peasants were being mistreated by the Nationalists by improving conditions for them ending traditional practices like arranged marriages and by effectively using propaganda in the form of artwork to convince the people that the Nationalists were cruel and corrupt while the Communists were willing to work together for the common good. Gaining the support of peasants greatly increased the size of the People's Liberation Army, giving it a good chance of successfully attacking the Guomindang directly.

Despite the importance of the above strategies, some historians argue that assistance from Soviet Russia was the most important factor of the Communists' victory. Russia sent help to the Chinese Communist Party in the form of spies and military advisors. Spies gathered intelligence from the Nationalists to give to the Communists, while advisors like Otto Braun provided knowledge of strategies and tactics that could be used against the Guomindang.

Explain two major political effects of the Chinese Civil War.

One major political effect of the Chinese Civil War was the alliance that was formed between Russia and China during the Cold War. When the Communists won the civil war in 1949, they set up the government known as the People's Republic of China, which shared some policies and ideals with the USSR. Because of this, when tensions increased between Communism and the West, China and Russia agreed to help each other, signing a Mutual Aid Treaty in 1950.

Similarly to how Communism spread from Russia to China, it also began to spread from China to the rest of Asia. The United States saw this as a major threat, and so it adopted a policy of containment, meaning that it would try to stop the spread of Communism throughout the world at all costs. This resulted in multiple wars, including the Korean War and the Vietnam War.

Explain two major economic effects of the Chinese Civil War.

The fighting that took place during the Chinese Civil War caused much of China's infrastructure to be damaged, which had a very negative effect on the nation's economy. Inflation was a large part of this, with the price of food increasing greatly beyond what it had been in the past. In an attempt to improve the economic situation, the People's Liberation Army was put to work repairing infrastructure such as bridges and railways.

Another economic effect of the war was the implementation of collective farming among peasant communities. This was very similar to what was done by other communist leaders, such as Stalin. Rather than giving land to individual peasants, land was taken away from wealthier peasants and land owners to be shared and farmed by groups of peasants collectively.

Test Review

2 Political Causes
  • Russian Revolution
  • Downfall of the Manchu Dynasty
2 Social Causes
  • Rise of Chinese nationalism
  • New Tide
3 Strategies that helped the Communists win
  • Guerrilla Warfare (Long March)
  • Aid from Russians (Advisors like
  • Getting the support of civilians
2 Political Effects
  • Russia and China form an alliance in the Cold War
  • Communism spreads through Asia, causing the West to adopt a policy of containment
2 Economic Effects
  • Land reform/collectivization
  • The PLA is put to work rebuilding China's infrastructure